5 Great Neighborhoods in Sarasota

Get to know these sought-after communities on the west coast of Florida.
By: Susan Ladika

DOWNTOWN
Laurel Park

Looking for history combined with walkability? Check out Laurel Park in downtown Sarasota. In 2008, this neighborhood was designated a National Register of Historic Places District. The neighborhood is filled with single-family homes, duplexes and small apartment buildings, with many dating back to the 1920s, in styles such as bungalow, Mission revival, Colonial revival and Mediterranean revival. If a neighborhood filled with historic homes, brick-lined streets and trees dripping with Spanish moss isn’t enough, it’s within a stone’s throw of downtown shops, restaurants and entertainment. Residents run the spectrum from professionals to artists, and young families to retirees, not to mention plenty of pets.  

NORTH
Gillespie Park

While it may not be for everyone, Gillespie Park is a neighborhood on the upswing. Renovated 1920s bungalows, ranch-style homes from the 1950s and 1960s, small apartment buildings and a smattering of new construction make the neighborhood just north of downtown an interesting mix. Named in honor of Sarasota’s first mayor, John Gillespie, the neighborhood’s centerpiece is a sprawling park of the same name, boasting a lake with a refreshing fountain. The neighborhood has a diverse population base, bringing together renters and property owners. It’s also a quick walk to the shops of Main Street. 

EAST OF TRAIL
Lakewood Ranch

This sprawling planned community east of Interstate 75 on the Sarasota-Manatee county line offers something for everyone, from townhouses to million-dollar-plus estate homes. You’ll find everyone from young families to empty-nesters living in the seven villages that make up Lakewood Ranch. You’ll also find recreation ranging from playgrounds to pools to polo, with half of the 8,500-acre community set aside for open space and recreation areas, including miles of hiking trails. Several village centers have been established, so there are plenty of shopping and dining opportunities close to home. Lakewood Ranch also has the distinction of being a green community, and since 2005, new construction is required to follow Florida Green Building Coalition standards.  

WEST OF TRAIL
Indian Beach Sapphire Shores

This bayfront neighborhood in the shadow of the historic Ringling estate is filled with historic homes dating to the 1920s, along with modern mansions and more moderately priced homes. Because of its location near New College of Florida and the Ringling College of Art and Design, the neighborhood draws wealthy professionals and families as well as professors and college students. With its location along Sarasota Bay, neighbors often gather at the Sapphire Shores and Indian Beach parks to watch the sunset. 

ISLAND
Siesta Key

If you’re looking for that laid-back, beach vibe, take a look at Siesta Key, which has consistently won accolades for its sparkling sand. Sure there are the obligatory condominiums and manicured subdivisions, but the south tip of the key, in the Turtle Beach area, swims in tropical foliage, giving it the feeling of an old-time Florida resort. The north end of the key has Siesta Village, a compact downtown with a number of beachy restaurants serving up fresh seafood, cold beers and beach music. While Siesta Key’s population runs the gamut, be prepared for an influx of tourists and snowbirds during the winter season. 

View of Siesta Key beach in Sarasota Florida

View of Siesta Key beach in Sarasota Florida

Next Up

5 Great Neighborhoods in Seattle

Seattle has a neighborhood for every lifestyle, with lofts offering scenic views of Puget Sound and Olympic mountains to single-family homes and mansions in commercial areas.

5 Great Neighborhoods in Savannah

Browse this guide of Savannah's top neighborhoods.

5 Great Neighborhoods in Raleigh

Check out this guide to Raleigh, North Carolina's most popular neighborhoods.

5 Great Neighborhoods in Tucson

Tour Tucson's most popular communities, from Sam Hughes and its colorful bungalows to Civano and its solar-powered adobe homes.

5 Great Neighborhoods in Orlando

North, south, east, west—all directions point to intriguing neighborhoods in Orlando. Take a tour with Great American Country.

5 Great Neighborhoods in Sonoma

Get to know the best places to call home in this historic California town.

5 Great Neighborhoods in St. Louis

Find the St. Louis neighborhood where you can make yourself at home with this guide.

5 Great Neighborhoods in Steamboat Springs

Find out why these neighborhoods are Steamboat Springs' most popular picks.

5 Great Neighborhoods in Santa Fe

Get the scoop on some of the top places to live in this Southwestern town.

5 Great Neighborhoods in West Palm Beach

Explore West Palm Beach's top neighborhoods and meet the people who live there.

Top GAC Shows

Flea Market Flip

Sundays 8pm | 7c

Living Alaska

Tuesdays 9pm | 8c

Top 20 Countdown

Consult Program Guide

Flippin' RVs

Wednesdays 9|8c

Get Social With Us

Let's explore this country together.